Legitimate Expectations and Proportionality in Administrative Law

Legitimate Expectations and Proportionality in Administrative Law PDF

Author: Robert Thomas

Publisher: Hart Publishing

Published: 2000-09

Total Pages: 146

ISBN-13: 1841130869

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

Presents a comparison of the development in European and English law of two legal principles, legitimate expectations and proportionality, against the different traditions of administrative law. Looks at case law of the English courts and the European Court of Justice, and explains why English courts have been troubled by legitimate expectations and proportionality and how such difficulties can be resolved. Suggests that problems associated with these principles are connected to different cultural approaches to the appropriate role of law in the modern state. Of interest to administrative lawyers. The author teaches law at the University of Manchester. Distributed by ISBS. c. Book News Inc.

Legitimate Expectations in Administrative Law

Legitimate Expectations in Administrative Law PDF

Author: Søren J. Schønberg

Publisher: Oxford University Press on Demand

Published: 2000

Total Pages: 270

ISBN-13: 9780198299479

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

This original and stimulating book is the first systematic study of the principle of `legitimate expectations' in administrative law to appear in the English language. The notion of reasonable or legitimate expectations has played a central role in the development of administrative law over the last thirty years and it remains one of the most contentious and most frequently invoked grounds of judicial review. In this book Dr Schonberg provides a detailed, comparative, and critical analysis of that notion He begins by clarifying why administrative law should protect expectations at all, by linking expectations to fairness, trust in administration, and the Rule of Law with its requirements of legal certainty and formal equality. In the light of this framework he examines in detail the principles and rules which contribute to the protection of expectations. The scope of this analysis is broad, looking both at procedural and substantive principles of administrative law as wellas principles of tort liability and stautory compensation. In all of these areas, English law is carefully compared with French and EC law and is shown how the three legal systems often reach similar outcomes by the application of different legal principles and rules. The current state of English law is examined critically in the light of the comparative study of French and EC law, and a number of original suggestions for legal reform are presented. They include the adoption of: a generalprinciple of irrevocability of intra vires administrative decisions, a distinct principle of substantive legitimate expectations subject to a `significant imbalance' threshold for judicial intervention, and a statutory right to compensation for loss caused by `sufficiently serious' violations of public law.

A Theory of Legitimate Expectations for Public Administration

A Theory of Legitimate Expectations for Public Administration PDF

Author: Alexander Brown

Publisher: Oxford University Press

Published: 2017-12-08

Total Pages: 409

ISBN-13: 0192545566

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

It is an unfortunate but unavoidable feature of even well-ordered democratic societies that governmental administrative agencies often create legitimate expectations (procedural or substantive) on the part of non-governmental agents (individual citizens, groups, businesses, organizations, institutions, and instrumentalities) but find themselves unable to fulfil those expectations for reasons of justice, the public interest, severe financial constraints, and sometimes harsh political realities. How governmental administrative agencies, operating on behalf of society, handle the creation and frustration of legitimate expectations implicates a whole host of values that we have reason to care about, including under non-ideal conditions-not least justice, fairness, autonomy, the rule of law, responsible uses of power, credible commitments, reliance interests, security of expectations, stability, democracy, parliamentary supremacy, and legitimate authority. This book develops a new theory of legitimate expectations for public administration drawing on normative arguments from political and legal theory. Brown begins by offering a new account of the legitimacy of legitimate expectations. He argues that it is the very responsibility of governmental administrative agencies for creating expectations that ought to ground legitimacy, as opposed to the justice or the legitimate authority of those agencies and expectations. He also clarifies some of the main ways in which agencies can be responsible for creating expectations. Moreover, he argues that governmental administrative agencies should be held liable for losses they directly cause by creating and then frustrating legitimate expectations on the part of non-governmental agents and, if liable, have an obligation to make adequate compensation payments in respect of those losses.

Evolution and Application of the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation in Administrative Law

Evolution and Application of the Doctrine of Legitimate Expectation in Administrative Law PDF

Author: Apoorwa Nanayakkara

Publisher:

Published: 2023

Total Pages: 0

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

This article delves into the evolution and application of the doctrine of legitimate expectation in administrative law, exploring its fundamental principles and implications. The concept of legitimate expectation has emerged as a vital bridge between the Rule of Estoppel and the Principle of Administrative Fairness, serving to safeguard individuals against arbitrary exercise of power by state agencies. Further examines the theoretical underpinnings of legitimate expectation, its procedural and substantive aspects, and its significance in ensuring good governance. Through an analysis of key cases from different jurisdictions, including Sri Lanka, the article evaluates the development of the doctrine and its interplay with principles of natural justice and equality. The article also discusses the challenges and ambiguities faced in distinguishing between procedural and substantive legitimate expectations. Overall, it highlights the importance of maintaining a delicate balance between protecting legitimate expectations and prioritizing the public interest, while emphasizing the evolving nature of this doctrine within the realm of administrative law.

The Protection of Legitimate Expectations in Administrative Law

The Protection of Legitimate Expectations in Administrative Law PDF

Author: Anneken Kari Sperr

Publisher: Hart Publishing

Published: 2021-03-11

Total Pages: 480

ISBN-13: 9781849465410

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

The protection of legitimate expectations appears to be a key concept of administrative law in Europe; it defines the legal position of the individual vis-à-vis the public authorities and is, thus, a gateway for constitutional considerations in administrative law. This book presents the results of a comparative research project dealing with the question if, to what extent, and in which ways the legitimate expectations of private parties are considered in procedures leading to a primary administrative decision and, where available, in subsequent review procedures before administrative, judicial or quasi-judicial bodies. Furthermore, the project examines if, and to what extent, European and national legal orders, as well as international legal regimes, guarantee compensation in cases where provisions concerning the protection of legitimate expectations have been disregarded. The contributions to the book, including surveys of the theoretical and philosophical background, country reports and comparative analyses, are written by scholars from 16 European countries, giving an insight into the various legal systems, their understanding of, and their methods of interpreting and applying, administrative law.

Legitimate Expectations in the Common Law World

Legitimate Expectations in the Common Law World PDF

Author: Matthew Groves

Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing

Published: 2017-01-12

Total Pages: 536

ISBN-13: 1509909508

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

The recognition and enforcement of legitimate expectations by courts has been a striking feature of English law since R v North and East Devon Health Authority; ex parte Coughlan [2001] 3 QB 213. Although the substantive form of legitimate expectation adopted in Coughlan was quickly accepted by English courts and received a generally favourable response from public law scholars, the doctrine of that case has largely been rejected in other common law jurisdictions. The central principles of Coughlan have been rejected by courts in common law jurisdictions outside the UK for a range of reasons, such as incompatibility with local constitutional doctrine, or because they mark an undesirable drift towards merits review. The sceptical and critical reception to Coughlan outside England is a striking contrast to the reception the case received within the UK. This book provides a detailed scholarly analysis of these issues and considers the doctrine of legitimate expectations both in England and elsewhere in the common law world.

Understanding Administrative Law in the Common Law World

Understanding Administrative Law in the Common Law World PDF

Author: Paul Daly

Publisher: Oxford University Press

Published: 2021

Total Pages: 321

ISBN-13: 0192896911

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

A new framework for understanding contemporary administrative law, through a comparative analysis of case law from Australia, Canada, England, Ireland, and New Zealand. The author argues that the field is structured by four values: individual self-realisation, good administration, electoral legitimacy and decisional autonomy.

The Anatomy of Administrative Law

The Anatomy of Administrative Law PDF

Author: Joanna Bell

Publisher: Bloomsbury Publishing

Published: 2020-05-28

Total Pages: 256

ISBN-13: 150992535X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

This book seeks to further our understanding of the nature of administrative law doctrine and adjudication. It has three main aims. The first is to improve understanding of administrative law's 'anatomy' by pulling the subject apart and exploring the nature of the legal structures at play in adjudication. In doing so, the book emphasises three main ways in which administrative law's anatomy is both complex and diverse, namely: - administrative law doctrine interacts with a broad array of legislative frameworks; - administrative law adjudication seeks to accommodate a variety of legal values; and, - administrative law is concerned with legal relationships of different kinds. The second aim is to illustrate the importance of recognising the complexity and variety of administrative law's anatomy in three particular doctrinal contexts: procedural review, legitimate expectations and standing. The third and final aim is to raise an important but under-explored question: is it plausible and useful to attempt to make sense of administrative law doctrine by reference to a singular organising concept or principle? The overarching message of the book is one of cynicism. The complexity and variety of administrative law's legal structures probably means that attempts to explain the field 'monistically', while they may capture important themes, will be unhelpfully reductionist. Ambitious and thought-provoking, this is an important new statement on administrative law.

Textbook on Administrative Law

Textbook on Administrative Law PDF

Author: Peter Leyland

Publisher: Oxford University Press, USA

Published: 2013

Total Pages: 545

ISBN-13: 0199601666

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

The seventh edition of Textbook on Administrative Law continues to provide students with an accessible and stimulating guide to the subject. Practical in approach, the authors concentrate on fully analysing core topics, while at the same time setting them within a contextual and thematic framework.