Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence

Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence PDF

Author: Kate Fitz-Gibbon

Publisher: Springer

Published: 2014-09-23

Total Pages: 431

ISBN-13: 113735755X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

This book critically examines the operation of the partial defence of provocation in a range of comparative international jurisdictions. Centrally concerned with conceptual questions of gender, justice and the role of denial in the criminal justice system, Fitz-Gibbon explores the divergent approaches taken to reforming the law of provocation.

The Aftermath of Provocation

The Aftermath of Provocation PDF

Author: Kate Esther Fitz-Gibbon

Publisher:

Published: 2012

Total Pages: 616

ISBN-13:

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

Over the past decade, homicide law reform surrounding the partial defences to murder has animated debate among criminological scholars and legal stakeholders in Australia and the United Kingdom. In response to these debates, criminal jurisdictions have conducted reviews of the partial defences to murder and implemented reforms targeted at reducing gender bias in the law which has played out through the operation of the partial defence of provocation. This research examines the different approaches taken to addressing the problem posed by provocation in Victoria, New South Wales and England. In doing so, it explores questions around the need for reform to the law of homicide, the effects of these reforms in practice, and the influential role of sentencing in questions surrounding homicide law reform. Throughout the analysis key frameworks of criminological thought in relation to feminist engagements with the law, the conceptualisation of denial and the influence of law and order politics upon the development of criminal justice policy are applied. By drawing on 81 in-depth interviews conducted with legal stakeholders across the three jurisdictions under study, and an analysis of relevant case law, this research concludes that reforms implemented to counter gender bias in the operation of homicide law have produced mixed results in practice, particularly in connection to the law's response to three key categories of person in the courtroom: the jealous man, the female victim of homicide, and the battered woman.

Sex, Culpability, and the Defence of Provocation

Sex, Culpability, and the Defence of Provocation PDF

Author: Danielle Tyson

Publisher: Routledge

Published: 2013

Total Pages: 250

ISBN-13: 0415560179

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

Dealing with the complex case law concerning the use of the provocation defence in cases of intimate killings, Sex, Culpability and the Defence of Provocation considers the construction and representation of subjectivity and sexual difference in legal narrations of homicide.

Homicide and the Politics of Law Reform

Homicide and the Politics of Law Reform PDF

Author: Jeremy Horder

Publisher: OUP Oxford

Published: 2012-07-12

Total Pages: 528

ISBN-13: 0191635952

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

What makes murder, murder? How should we understand the difference between intentional and reckless killing? Should offenders be punished differently according to the perceived severity of their crime and when should they be excused? These questions are the topic of intense debate within legal circles and beyond in the UK, the US, and the rest of world. Jeremy Horder's role as the Law Commissioner for England and Wales on criminal law has given him unique insight into these questions and the debates surrounding them. Here he analyses the recent political and legal reform movements, offering a political history of homicide law reform from the 19th century to the modern era. Using homicide as a starting point, Horder raises deeper questions of who is and should be responsible for making and changing the law. What role should there be for expert bodies, judges, and politicians? What role should there be for the general public? These questions invoke strong emotional responses. Horder argues that comprehensive research into, and a degree of difference to, public opinion on the scope of homicide is essential to the reform process. It is essential principally as a means of conferring true legitimacy on homicide reform in a democracy. Elite or expert opinion alone will never authentically secure such legitimacy. Offering an insider's view into the processes of achieving law reform, Horder expresses criticism of a system that excludes the vast majority of people from consultation on reform of the laws that govern them.

Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence

Homicide Law Reform, Gender and the Provocation Defence PDF

Author: Kate Fitz-Gibbon

Publisher: Springer

Published: 2014-09-23

Total Pages: 322

ISBN-13: 113735755X

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

This book critically examines the operation of the partial defence of provocation in a range of comparative international jurisdictions. Centrally concerned with conceptual questions of gender, justice and the role of denial in the criminal justice system, Fitz-Gibbon explores the divergent approaches taken to reforming the law of provocation.

Homicide, Gender and Responsibility

Homicide, Gender and Responsibility PDF

Author: Kate Fitz-Gibbon

Publisher: Routledge

Published: 2016-03-22

Total Pages: 203

ISBN-13: 1317550625

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

The crime of homicide has long animated academic debate, community concern and political attention. The discussion has often centered on the perceived (in)adequacy of legal responses to homicide, questions of culpability, and divergent representations of victims and offenders. Within this, notions of gender, responsibility and justice are pivotal. This edited collection builds on existing scholarship by examining these concerns not only in the context of the ‘private’ world of domestic murder but also in the more ‘public’ world of the state, the corporation, war, and genocide. In so doing this book draws from key frameworks of criminological thought, legal analysis and empirical evidence to critically examine the relationship between homicide, gender and responsibility. Bringing together leading international criminology and legal scholars, this collection provides a unique contribution to the academic and policy engagement with what is, more often than not, an ordinary and mundane crime. Analysing the crime in a variety of different social contexts alongside an in-depth and critical analysis of the interconnections between the ordinary act of lethal violence, gender and notions of responsibility, this book will be of interest to students, scholars and policymakers working in criminology and socio-legal studies.

Women, Murder and Justice

Women, Murder and Justice PDF

Author: W. Chan

Publisher: Springer

Published: 2001-01-11

Total Pages: 255

ISBN-13: 0230596665

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

Women, Murder and Justice examines from a feminist perspective, the legal treatment of women who kill their partners in England. Through an exploration of Crown Prosecution Service files, an in-depth comparative examination of the circumstances in which women and men kill is provided. The book highlights gender differences in the act of murder, the criminal justice system's negotiation of these differences, and the development of feminist strategies to alter the legal structure for women who kill.

Homicide and the Politics of Law Reform

Homicide and the Politics of Law Reform PDF

Author: Jeremy Horder

Publisher: Oxford University Press

Published: 2012-07-12

Total Pages: 296

ISBN-13: 0199561915

DOWNLOAD EBOOK →

A fascinating study of the law of homicide, examining its recent development and providing an insider's view on the politics of law reform. Challenging current thought, it argues for the general public to have a greater role in the process of law reform including offenses such as murder, manslaughter, and the highly debated corporate homicide.